Amara Cay Resort Islamorada, Islamorada - Reviews, Room Options & Prices 2025

Book and save

up to 10%

compared to Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, Florida, United States of America, 33036

The 4-star Amara Cay Resort in Islamorada features a zero-entry pool with Alligator Reef Lighthouse views, private beach access, and a marina accommodating boats up to 24 feet.

Coastal Room Features

Guest rooms at Amara Cay Resort offer private furnished balconies or lanais, premium bedding with triple sheeting, and upscale toiletries. Each room includes a 32-inch HD television and workspaces.

Waterfront Dining Options

ReelCatch restaurant serves island-inspired seafood and fresh breakfast, while Tiki Bar offers poolside American cuisine and tropical cocktails. Coastal Cup provides grab-and-go breakfast items and specialty beverages.

Resort Activities

The resort features complimentary paddleboard and kayak rentals, daily bicycle access, and boat excursion partnerships. The Glass Bowl meeting room accommodates 50 guests for business events.

Transport and Location

Located near Lignumvitae Key Botanical State Park, the property offers complimentary shuttle service within a four-mile radius and water taxi access to sister resorts.

View all

Select your room type

The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

Quadruple Room

Max:

4 persons

35 m²

Bed options:

2 King Size Beds

Sea view

Balcony

room details

Check Prices

Oceanfront Queen Room

Max:

4 persons

35 m²

Bed options:

2 King Size Beds

Sea view

Balcony

room details

Check Prices

Suite

Max:

6 persons

60 m²

Bed options:

2 King Size Beds

Sea view

Balcony

room details

Check Prices

Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

A guide to all available transportation options

City Center

Islamorada 2.4 mi

Bus

Bus stop 5.2 mi

Facilities

Experience a variety of amenities at the boutique hotel, crafted to ensure your comfort and unforgettable moments

Paid Wi-Fi

Parking

Paid parking

Baggage storage

24-hour services

24-hour reception

General

Non-smoking rooms
Paid Wi-Fi
Parking
24-hour reception
Express check-in/ -out
Pets allowed
Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
Wheelchair access
Security
Baggage storage
Private beach
Elevator
Smoke detectors
Electric vehicle charging station
Key card access

Sports & Fitness

Fitness center
Diving
Snorkeling
Cycling
Golf course
Fishing

Services

Free shuttle service
Pet amenities available
Room service
Housekeeping
Laundry
Stores/Commercial services
Welcome drink

Dining

Restaurant
Poolside snack bar
Snack bar
Special diet menus

Business

Meeting/ Banquet facilities
Fax/Photocopying

Children

Children's menu

Facilities for people with disabilities

Toilet for disabled

Spa & Leisure

Heated swimming pool
Outdoor swimming pool
Beach access
Beach umbrellas
Sun loungers
Sun terrace
Garden area
Leisure/ TV room
Pool with view
Shallow end

Room features

Air conditioning
Garden furniture
Tea and coffee facilities

Media

AM/FM alarm clock

Location

80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, Florida, United States of America, 33036

Map view

80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, Florida, United States of America, 33036

City landmarks

Mile Marker 78.5

Indian Key State Historic Site

1.1 mi

U.S. 1 at Mile Marker 78.5 77200 Overseas Highway

Lignumvitae Key Botanical State Park

1.1 mi

Gallery

Pasta Pantaleo Signature Gallery

1.5 mi

81011 Overseas Hwy

FNX Club by Islamorada Fitness

4900 ft

Monuments and Landmarks

Hurricane Monument

1.7 mi

Gallery

Gallery Morada

1.5 mi

Island

Upper Matecumbe Key

1.9 mi

Anne s Beach

1.7 mi

81868 Overseas Hwy

In the Doghouse Art Studio

1.8 mi

Gallery

Michelle Nicole Lowe Art Gallery

1.9 mi

Gallery

Roberto Pasta Pantaleo Gallery

1.5 mi

Mile 81.6 bayside

Morada Bay

1.5 mi

Gallery

Portside Studio & Gallery

1.5 mi

Florida Keys Memorial

1.7 mi

Gallery

Elena Madden Studio Gallery

1.6 mi

Museums

History of Diving Museum

3.0 mi

Church

Matecumbe United Methodist Church

1.7 mi

Island

Plantation Key

1.8 mi

Island

Raccoon Key

1.8 mi

Carysfort Reef

1.8 mi

Gallery

Lobster Trap Art Gift Shop and Gallery

2.2 mi

Saint James the Fisherman Episcopal Church

1.9 mi

Parks

Indian Key Historic State Park

2.0 mi

Museums

Florida Keys History and Discovery Center

2.2 mi

82100 Overseas Hwy

Keys History & Discovery Center

2.2 mi

9700 Old State Rd 4a

Cheeca Rocks

2.4 mi

Lignumvitae Key

2.7 mi

First Baptist Church

2.8 mi

Mile 83

Florida Keys History of Diving Museum

3.0 mi

Nearby

U.S. 1 at Mile Marker 78.5 77200 Overseas Highway

Lignumvitae Key Botanical State Park

0 ft

Restaurants

Reelburger

600 ft

80001 Overseas Hwy

Galley Girls Cafe

1700 ft

79851 Overseas Hwy Mile marker 79.8

Kev's Cafe

1700 ft

79851 Overseas Hwy

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback from previous guests about their experience.

82%

enjoyed the hotel and would happily stay again

8.2/10

Great

Rooms

7.4

Location

8.4

Service

7.2

Dining

6.8

4/5 based on 2018 reviews

#8 of 20 hotels in Islamorada based on Tripadvisor

Mike

United States of America, March 2025

5.8/10

I just wrapped up a couple of days at Amara Cay Resort and I loved it! The ocean views were stunning and the beach area was super relaxing with plenty of lounge chairs. However, my experience was slightly dampened by the restaurant service being a bit inconsistent, which could definitely improve.

Rooms

8.0

My room, #517, was stylish and had a nice side view of the ocean, making my mornings feel special. Although it was well-decorated, there were moments I felt the room could benefit from a refresh.

Service

7.0

The staff were friendly and accommodating, especially the front desk who changed my room when I wasn't satisfied. Still, the restaurant service was slow at times which took away from the overall experience.

Location

9.0

Located on the Atlantic side of the Keys, Amara Cay offers a peaceful atmosphere close to great dining options. The beach and pool area were convenient for relaxation and water sports.

Dining

6.0

I had a delicious breakfast at the hotel, but the lunch options at the tiki bar were pretty limited. I recommend checking out some local spots for lunch or dinner, like Morada Bay for sunsets.

Facilities

7.0

The pool is nice and well-maintained, and I enjoyed the kayaking and paddleboarding. However, the gym felt a bit cramped, so I opted for outdoor activities instead.

Carlos

United States of America, February 2025

6.4/10

I had a lovely stay at Amara Cay Resort, enjoying the beautiful ocean views and the spacious pool area. The staff was friendly and helpful, which made my experience more enjoyable. However, there were moments where I felt the service could improve, particularly during peak times at the bar, leading to minor inconveniences. Overall, it's a great spot if you're looking for a laid-back vibe in the Keys.

Rooms

8.0

The room I stayed in was spacious and well-equipped. I appreciated the comfortable bedding and access to amenities. However, I did notice that some photos online didn't quite match the room specifications, which was a little misleading.

Service

7.0

The staff were generally friendly and accommodating, making efforts to check on how my stay was going. However, there were a few moments where things could have been more organized, especially during busy times.

Location

9.0

The resort is beautifully situated right on the water, providing amazing views and easy access to local eateries. I loved waking up to the scenic beach and swaying palm trees.

Dining

8.0

I enjoyed the food at the resort; it was delicious, though some meals felt a bit on the pricier side. The breakfast was worth trying, especially for the quality.

Facilities

9.0

The facilities were impressive, with a nice pool area and beach access. It was great to have access to kayaks and paddleboards without additional fees. There were also fun activities organized, making it family-friendly.

John

United States of America, January 2025

6.6/10

My stay at Amara Cay Resort was enjoyable overall, primarily due to the beautiful ocean views and the relaxing pool area. However, the high prices for cocktails at the bar were off-putting and the room could have been more spacious in the bathroom. Despite these minor setbacks, I appreciated the friendly staff, who were eager to help, and I loved the modern decor throughout the hotel.

Rooms

7.0

The room was flawlessly clean and beautifully decorated, featuring wood flooring and an ocean view. However, I found the bathroom quite cramped, lacking sufficient space for toiletries, which was disappointing given the room's price.

Service

8.0

The staff was mostly friendly and helpful, always willing to assist. While they promptly responded to my requests, they could have been more attentive to my initial concerns about the room.

Location

9.0

The resort's location offers stunning oceanfront views and easy access to various activities, like kayaking and paddleboarding. In the mornings, the setting is perfect for a quick swim before breakfast, with ample comfortable seating available.

Dining

7.0

I found the food overall to be above average, though breakfast could start earlier than 7:30 for those eager to grab coffee in the morning. The prices were on the higher side, making it a bit of a splurge.

Facilities

8.0

The resort had great facilities, including a lovely pool area and a cozy Tiki Bar, although the pricing for drinks was pretty steep. The shuttle service was convenient for getting around easily.

George

United States of America, January 2025

6.6/10

My stay at Amara Cay Resort was quite the experience. The oceanfront views from my room were stunning, and the amenities like the pool and Tiki Bar added to the enjoyment. However, there were noticeable issues like the underwhelming beach area and some lapses in service that detracted from my overall experience.

Rooms

6.0

I stayed in an oceanfront suite that was spacious and well-decorated, but the sofa bed was dirty and uncomfortable. I had to call for bedding that wasn't provided originally, which was frustrating. While the overall comfort was decent, the lighting could definitely use an upgrade.

Service

6.0

The staff were generally friendly, but my experience was mixed. There were some delays in drink service at the bar, and the organization could be improved. They did go the extra mile to resolve some issues at checkout, which I appreciated, though it felt like a hassle at times.

Location

6.0

The resort had an idyllic location with beautiful landscaping and access to local dining options. However, the beach was disappointing with its concrete wall and rocky access to the water, which made it less appealing for swimming or relaxing by the shore.

Dining

6.0

I only had breakfast at the on-site restaurant, which served wonderful food, but I found the prices for dinner a bit steep considering the portion sizes. I also noticed some inconsistencies in service during meals that could use addressing.

Facilities

6.0

The amenities available, like water sports equipment and the pool, were nice touches. I enjoyed the courtyard area with games and lounge spots, but I encountered equipment issues during my gym visit that required maintenance. Overall, the facilities had a lot of potential.

Luke

United States of America, November 2024

6.0/10

My stay at Amara Cay Resort was quite enjoyable. The beautiful ocean views and relaxing pool area were definite highlights. though I did encounter a few issues with the WiFi and some worn beach lounge chairs. Overall, it provided a great atmosphere for a peaceful getaway.

Rooms

8.0

While my room was clean and updated, it lacked some amenities that could have enhanced the experience, such as more natural light. I was happy with the upgraded suite I chose for the ocean views.

Service

8.0

The staff was friendly and welcoming, always eager to help. However, some requests took longer than expected to fulfill, which was a bit frustrating.

Location

9.0

The resort's location was convenient, with easy access to local attractions and dining options. The shuttle service was a great perk for getting around the area.

Dining

7.0

The dining options at the Tiki Bar were fantastic, especially the fresh seafood dishes. though I found some menu items to be a bit overpriced.

Facilities

8.0

Amara Cay offered a lovely pool area and well-maintained grounds. The availability of kayaking and paddleboarding made for some fun afternoons. The beach area, while not a traditional one, provided a nice place to relax.